I cannot say enough good things about this bakery. 5 stars are simply not enough for the quality of the goodies and the level of customer service that you receive...
If you order in advance, you literally receive fresh bread, cookies, pie right out of the oven! I divide my time between Pocono Pines and Manhattan and this is my favorite bakery of both places. They feed your stomach and your heart.
Menu Snapshot
Available in our Pocono Lake shop on a rotating schedule and for pre-order. Items in the shop are subject to change and may sell out. [Fall Menu as of October 8]
* = pre-order only. Call or email us to place your order.
Pies
Galettes, Tarts & Tortes
$15 | $16
Apple: Crumb | Old-Fashioned
$15 | $16
$17
Caramel Apple
$17
$16
Banana Pudding
$16
$18
Blackberry Pear Streusel
$18
$18
Maple Blueberry
wild blueberries, lattice crust
$18
$16
Bourbon Vanilla Cream
$16
$17
Browned-Butter Vanilla Pear
$17
$18
Spiced Cherry
organic bing cherries, lattice crust
$18
$19
Cream Puff Pie
$19
$20
German Chocolate*
deep chocolate, traditional coconut pecan topping
$20
$18
Orange Cranberry Crumb
can be ordered with fresh orange cream
$18
$15
Peaches-N-Cream
$15
$18
Pecan
$18
$20
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
$20
$17
Pumpkin
$17
$18
Pumpkin Chocolate
$18
$20
Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Chocolate
$20
$15
Shoofly
wet-bottom traditional PA Dutch treat
$15
$20
Vanilla Bourbon Cherry Blueberry
$20
$32
Apple Cheesecake Pie*
creamy cheesecake baked inside an old-fashioned apple
$32
$32
Blackberry Cheesecake Galette*
$32
$17 - $20
Fresh Fruit Tarts
traditional tart w/seasonal fruit and berries -- also prepared with gingersnap or vanilla wafer crusts and frangipane or mascarpone fillings
$17 - $20
$25
/
$28
Chocolate Torte* (gluten free) / with Chocolate Ganache
created with ground almonds
$25
/
$28
Custom Celebration Cakes
6" Round, serves 8-12 | 9" Round, serves up to 24
$36 and up
Funfetti (vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream)
$36 and up
$9": $65
PA Dutch Chocolate (aka German Chocolate)
$9": $65
$9": $68
Gingerbread w/Brown Sugar Bourbon Frosting
$9": $68
$9": $70
S'mores Cake w/Marshmallow Buttercream & Chocolate Ganache
$9": $70
$9", 3-layer: $84
Hot Chocolate w/Marshmallow Buttercream
$9", 3-layer: $84
$9": $65
Carrot Cake w/Cheesecake Layer & Cream Cheese Frosting
$9": $65
$9": $68
Strawberry Champagne w/Fresh Strawberry Whipped Cream
$9": $68
$9": $68
Banana Cake w/Brown Sugar Cream Cheese Frosting
$9": $68
$36 and up
Build Your Own
$36 and up
Bread & Rolls
$6.25
Dakota Multigrain
$6.25
$5.99
Peasant Artisan White
$5.99
$5.99
Challah Braid
$5.99
$5.99
Semolina
$5.99
$6.25
Olive Rosemary
$6.25
$4.99
Garlic Potato
$4.99
$5.99
Whole Wheat
$5.99
$6.99
Pumpernickel Rye Braid
$6.99
$5.25
Amish White Sandwich Loaf
$5.25
$5.25
Honey Buttermilk Sandwich Loaf
$5.25
$5.99
Cinnamon Raisin Sandwich Loaf
$5.99
$4.50
/
$6
Brotchen Rolls
$4.50
/
$6
$6.50
/
$8
Buttery Soft Pull-Apart Rolls
$6.50
/
$8
$4.50
/
$6
Focaccia Ciabatta Rolls
$4.50
/
$6
$7.50
/
$6
Crusty Italian Sub Rolls
$7.50
/
$6
$5.75
/
$6
Bierock Burger Buns
$5.75
/
$6
Cookies
$8 | $15
Half Dozen | Dozen
Old-Fashioned Chocolate Chip, Old-Fashioned Dark Chocolate Chip, Vanilla Cranberry Chocolate Chip, Compost Bin, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter Cup, Snickerdoodles, Pumpkin Snickerdoodles, Spiced Ginger Molasses
$8 | $15
$9 | $17
Gluten-Free* (Half Dozen | Dozen)
Chocolate Chip, Monster
$9 | $17
$9 | $17
Specialty (Half Dozen | Dozen)
Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate, Cherry Winks, Date-Filled
$9 | $17
Pastries & Small Treats
$3
Cobbler Cinnamon Rolls
apple, caramel apple, apricot, blackberry, blueberry, peach, pear, raspberry, strawberry
$3
$2.75
Pecan Caramel Sticky Buns
$2.75
$1.25 - $2.25
Scones
apricot ginger, banana bread, cheddar, cheddar w/garlic and chive, lemon blueberry, maple bacon
$1.25 - $2.25
$2 - $2.25
Friendship Muffins
banana nut, blueberry, cranberry nut, chocolate chip, raspberry, strawberry
$2 - $2.25
$3 - $3.75
Brownies
plain, nut, peanut butter and jelly, cream cheese iced, chocolate ganache + buttercream, vanilla iced
$3 - $3.75
$3 - $4
Blondies
plain, triple chocolate butterscotch, irish coffee
$3 - $4
$4
Cookie Cheesecake Brownie*
fudge brownie layer, cheesecake layer, old-fashioned chocolate chip cookie layer
$4
$2.95 - $3.50
Mini Bundt Cakes
most available full size: almond poppyseed, lemon, pumpkin cranberry, pumpkin eggnog, apple spice, Oreo stuffed, vanilla sea salt
$2.95 - $3.50
Highly recommend. The bread is the best ever and the cookies and pies, delicious. Anyone we send here comes back thanking us.